Become a Votebeat sponsor

Apache County, Arizona, official who oversaw troubled Election Day is out

Navajo Nation officials had called for accountability after equipment failures left voters waiting in long lines.

Two people stand in front of ballot secrecy stands while voting in a room.
Voters mark their ballots at a polling station on the Navajo Nation in Fort Defiance, Arizona, on Election Day on Nov. 5, 2024. Voters across Apache County experienced long lines because of widespread equipment failures. (Andres Leighton / AP)

Votebeat is a nonprofit news organization reporting on voting access and election administration across the U.S. Sign up for Votebeat Arizona’s free newsletter here.

The official who oversaw Apache County’s November election during widespread technical problems at polling places is no longer in her position, Votebeat has learned.

Rita Vaughan is out as county elections director, JP Martin, a spokesperson for the Arizona Secretary of State’s Office confirmed. The county manager did not respond to a request for comment about the reasons for Vaughan’s departure, or the date she left. Vaughan also did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Voters and Navajo Nation officials have called for accountability after the Election Day problems across the county, which contains a large section of the Navajo Nation in the northeast corner of the state.

Voters seeking to cast ballots had to wait in lines for hours after the county’s equipment failed. Polling places that had emergency ballots quickly ran out, and for many voters, the only option was to use an accessible voting device until new equipment arrived, according to voters and observers. Polling places typically have only one or two of those accessible devices, which are designed for people with disabilities.

After the Navajo Nation sued on Election Day, an Apache County Superior Court judge ordered select polling places to stay open for two hours past the originally scheduled closing time. Lawyers for the Navajo Nation told the judge that, despite the county’s assertions, the problems persisted throughout the day, and some voters who were in line for hours in the cold chose to leave without voting.

Ethel Branch, the Navajo Nation Attorney General at the time, said later that month that the voters were disenfranchised.

“Despite this ruling, we will not be deterred from holding Apache County accountable for honoring all Navajo votes in future elections,” Branch wrote in a Nov. 22 Navajo Nation Department of Justice news release.

Vaughan told Votebeat on Election Day that the problem was with the county’s ballot-on-demand printers, and the county issued a news release saying the same. But county officials have not provided more details.

The Navajo Nation filed a second lawsuit after the election, asking a judge to provide more time for voters to fix problems with signatures on their ballots, because of delays in notifying voters of the problems. The county recorder, not the elections director, is in charge of that process. The judge dismissed that lawsuit.

Jen Fifield is a reporter for Votebeat based in Arizona. Contact Jen at jfifield@votebeat.org.

The Latest

The new security features, a response to years of false claims and conspiracy theories, will be introduced in the 2026 midterm election.

Opponents of the bill say some women who have changed their names could be turned away at the polls. Supporters say that concern is overblown.

Organizers of a petition drive get the go-ahead for their campaign to put the proposed requirement before voters in November 2026.

The state says a bill requiring counties to switch to TEAM would make it easier to monitor voter rolls. But the system has had its problems.

Democratic and nonprofit groups are pushing to halt implementation of the order on the grounds that it oversteps the president’s power.

Republicans across the country are pushing to require citizenship documents to register to vote. We want to hear your views.